Lord May of Oxford, the outgoing president of the Royal Society,
said that environmental campaigners risked holding back the fight
against climate change with an absolutist approach that refused to
consider nuclear power.
"I recognise there are huge problems with nuclear, but these have to
be weighed against other problems," Lord May said. "This has to be
recognised as a problem by what you might call a fundamentalist belief
system.
"Fundamentalism doesn’t necessarily derive from a sacred text. There
are also NGOs [non-governmental organisations] that are reluctant to
weigh one problem against another, but have a subset of problems that
are absolute and undiscussable."
He will go further in a valedictory speech today, linking such
opposition to a resurgent fundamentalism, more often displayed by
religious extremists, that threatens free scientific inquiry.
His warning came as Tony Blair announced to the CBI conference his
long-awaited energy review, which will recommend next summer whether to
start building new nuclear power stations in readiness for when the
present nuclear plants are due to be decommissioned in about 2020.
Mr Blair was prevented from making his speech in the main conference
hall by two Greenpeace demonstrators who climbed up an inside roof
overlooking the stage. Instead Mr Blair spoke in improvised form in a
crowded side meeting room.
The Prime Minister said that Britain and other countries would have
to diversify into several sources of energy and predicted that the
Kyoto Protocol governing carbon emissions, which expires in 2012, would
be followed by a binding international agreement covering all leading
economies.
"Energy prices have risen. Energy supply is under threat. Climate
change is producing a sense of urgency," Mr Blair said. "The future is
clean energy and nations will look to diversify out of energy
dependence on one source."
In 15 years Britain would have decommissioned both coal and nuclear
plants that between them accounted for 30 per cent of today’s
electricity supply, he said. "Some of this will be replaced by
renewables but not all of it can."
The CBI ordered an immediate review of its security after it was
discovered that the two Greenpeace protesters, who posed as conference
delegates, had paid for delegate passes through a bogus company,
E-Lingo, before scaling girders to reach the roof. The pair, Huw
Williams and Nyls Verhauelt, were later arrested.
Two legitimate passes were issued to Greenpeace delegates, although
the campaign group was refused permission to erect an exhibition stand
in the hall.
Malcolm Wicks, the Energy Minister, who will head the Government’s
review, said that it would consider ways of speeding up any planning
inquiries should new nuclear power stations be proposed. These would
require private investment but would need "some special relationship
between the market and the state in this area".
The review would also look at renewable energy, coal, gas and new
technologies, plus transport systems and energy efficiency, Mr Wicks
said. Its aim was to identify clean, reliable, affordable energy
supplies for the long term.
Charles Kennedy, the
Liberal Democrat leader, protested at the cost of disposing of nuclear
waste and the decommissioning of plants, saying that it would amount to
a "nuclear tax". The money would be better spent investing in renewable
energy and encouraging energy economy, he said.
The Conservatives welcomed the review but were non-committal on
nuclear power, although it is supported by a number of party figures.
Business organisations took a similar stance, saying that the
Government must develop a clear policy and secure energy supplies but
without taking sides over nuclear power.
Sir Digby Jones, Director-General of the CBI, would say only:
"Potential investors in new power generation plant require a clear and
stable framework from government in which to plan. We now need to see a
full and informed debate that engages the whole nation, and leads to a
clear conclusion — whatever that is."
But environmental groups urged ministers to reject the nuclear
option. Tony Juniper, of Friends of the Earth, said: "Nuclear power is
dangerous, expensive and unnecessary."